First Scully Biography Etches "The Best There Ever Was"

    Pull Up a Chair.jpg In 1950, William Faulkner wrote the Nobel Prize for Literature, "Tokyo Rose" went to prison, and South Pacific cried gotcha to the soul. More enduringly, Vin Scully, 22, joined Red Barber at Brooklyn's Ebbets Field: ultimately, the Roy Hobbs of baseball broadcasting, "the best there ever was."

           

Each game Scully asked the listener to "pull up a chair," inviting and compelling. Recently his first-ever biography, Pull Up a Chair: The Vin Scully Story, was released. Booklist hails "a synchronicity between author and subject that's as seemingly effortless and beautiful as a perfectly executed double play." The book is already in a second printing.            

           

This year the American Sportscasters Association named Scully "The Top Sportscaster of All-Time": at 81, still baseball's lingua franca, refusing to deviance- or dumb-down.  May I tell you about my book and its subject: a nonpareil announcer, and career?

 

Youth As Prologue

 

Pull Up a Chair begins with irony:  Born in the Yankees' Bronx in 1927, the son of Irish immigrants became a childhood Giants fan!  The émigrés often walked Vin in a baby carriage across Fordham University's Rose Hill campus. "Vincent," mother Bridget later said, "I dream that you will study here."

           

Scully's family lived on a fifth-floor flat in the Washington Heights section of northern Manhattan, within walking distance of the Polo Grounds and the Big Ballpark in the Bronx. "It is written that in every childhood a door will open," Vin once said, "and there's a quick glimpse of the future." His door opened at eight years of age.

           

In Scully's home sat a huge radio: "One of those deals," Vin said, "a monster with a wooden cross piece under it for support, its receiver high off the ground." Each Saturday he opened a box of crackers, poured a glass of milk, and literally crawled under the radio - sat under it -and heard Bill Stern, among others, broadcast college football.

           

"The sound washed over me," Scully said, "like water out of a showerhead": a tyke already intoxicated by the crowd. At 10, he and classmates were asked by the good Catholics Nuns what each hoped to be.  Most said a doctor, nurse, lawyer. Vin said, "I want to be a sportscaster."

           

Youth as prologue: Vin worked his way through Fordham Preparatory School, entered its University in 1944, spent a year in the Navy, then returned to campus. Friends recall him lugging a heavy tape recorder, broadcasting sotto voce. Scully played center field on the baseball team: good-field, no-hit, and very fast.  His nickname: The Phantom.

           

In 1947, Fordham trekked to New Haven to play Yale: its first baseman my future boss and friend: George H.W. Bush. Yale won, 2-1. As the 41st President said, years later, in a Scully video: "If I remember correctly, when we played each other, we each went 0 for 3."

           

Red By Any Name

 

In 1949, the soon-to-be graduate became a summer intern at 50,000-watt CBS affiliate   WTOP Washington: amazingly, the only station to reply among the 125 Scully wrote. He became a news, weather, and sports substitute for, among others, Arch McDonald, Voice of the Washington Senators: "First in War, First in Peace, and Last in the American League."

           

Since 1939, Barber had aired the Dodgers. A decade later, the also-CBS Radio Sports Red Barber at CBS.jpg director interviewed the intern. That fall, needing a sportscaster, Red phoned WTOP for references, then called Vin's home. Barber got Scully's mother, who that night greeted Vin at the door.

           

"You'll never guess who called today," Bridget said, red-haired and breathless. "It's such a great thing that he called here, such a busy man, it's so exciting.  He wants you to call him."

           

"Who was it?" Scully asked.

           

"Red Skelton," Mom said of the iconic comic.

           

The last laugh was not on Vin. Next day Barber gave him his first assignment: Boston University v. Maryland college football at Boston's Fenway Park. Expecting a covered booth, Scully broadcast from the roof: no press box, in freezing weather, never whispering a complaint.

           

Barber was impressed: much later, calling Vin "the son I never had." That winter, Ernie Harwell left the Dodgers for the hated Giants. Red chose Scully to succeed him. Six decades later, Harwell, laughing, terms it "my greatest contribution to baseball."

 

Throwing Darts in the Fog

 

How did Vin become what Jim Murray called "The Fordham Thrush with a .400 larynx"?  In Pull Up a Chair, I discuss what makes Scully, Scully: elusive, since defining art can rival throwing darts in the fog.

           

His goods tie credibility, proportion, knowledge, discipline, grasp of everyday hope and fear, and melodic Irish tenor less Pavarotti than Perry Como. The package has graced a nonpareil 25 World Series, 18 no-hitters, more games than anyone in broadcast history, 1979-97 CBS Radio, and 1983-89 NBC Television Game of the Week.

           

Vin has made the Hollywood Walk of Fame, won a lifetime Emmy Award, entered every major radio/TV Hall of Fame, and been voted "the most memorable personality in L.A. Dodgers history": connecting tissue between the public and its game. Churchill called "words you use as ammunition." Scully uses them against temptation to turn the dial.

           

Retrieve Vin's "twilight's little footsteps of sunshine."  Recall "He catches the gingerly, like a baby chick falling from the tree." One day a weak dribbler-turned infield hit prompted Eugene O'Neill's "A humble thing, but thine own." Another, a mutton-chopped player entered the game. "What ho! What ho!" said Vin, inspired. "What men are these, who wear their sideburns like parentheses?"

Of St. Louis: "It was so hot today the moon got sunburned."  Tom Glavine: "He pitches like a tailor: a little off here, a little off there, and you're done." A giveaway day at Dodger Stadium: "There's something redundant about giving noisemakers under 14 years of age." Rennie Stennett, giving out cigars, predicting his wife would have a boy. Said Scully of the girl: "[Stennett] only missed by one."

 

Perhaps Scully never went deeper than May 7, 1959.  In 1957, the Dodgers had left Brooklyn for Los Angeles. That winter catcher Roy Campanella was crippled in a crash. Now baseball's then-largest crowd, 93,103 at Memorial Coliseum, feted Campy before an exhibition.  Scully spoke magically, climbing a peak of place and mood.

           

"The lights are going out in this final tribute to Roy Campanella, and everyone at the ballpark ... are asked in silent tribute to light a match," he said. "The lights are now starting to come out, like thousands and thousands of fireflies, starting in center field, glittering around to left, and slowly the entire ballpark." Then: "A sea of lights at the Coliseum."

           

L.A. sees Vin's lights nightly. Others see them on satellite radio, Scully navigating dead air by using language as an oar. Once Andre Dawson made the disabled list. "He's day to day," Vin said. Pause. "Then, aren't we all?" His career is now year-to-year, still splicing a listener and the game.

 

Safe Harbor

 

Scully would have made a great politician, yet hated politics: too intrusive, too public, too little respect for silence. In 1955, Flatbush USA won its only world title. "Ladies and gentlemen, the Brooklyn Dodgers are the champions of the world," Vin said, simply. That winter people asked how he remained so calm. "If I'd said another word at that very instant, I'd have broken down and cried." Since then, his ammunition has often included silence.

 

1974: On a rainy night in Georgia, Henry Aaron's 715th homer crossed a most Ruthian line. Vin called the drive, moved to the back of the booth, poured a glass of water, and hushed for half-a-minute. Then: "A black man is getting a standing ovation in the Deep South for breaking the record of an all-time baseball idol!"

           

Segue to 1986. Bill Buckner's immemorial error froze time - and me, as a Red Sox fan. "Here comes Knight!" Vin said. "And the Mets win it!" Scully's usually singsong voice rocked, throbbed, alight with feel.  He then quieted for an entire minute.

           

1988: Kirk Gibson heroically went deep. Sixty-seven seconds later: "in a year that has been so improbable, the impossible has happened": still the 8-year-old, under the radio, letting the crowd hold sway.

           

Vin Scully 1.jpg It seems impossible that Scully will one day retire. Yet the Scully School can live:  vivid is good, personal better, and making the complex simple best. In today's 24/7 attention span-challenged age, most Voices fall to meet their audience. Scully asks his to rise.

On October 26, 1991, I worked all day on a Bush 41 address. At 10 P.M., I left the White House, found my car on the Ellipse, and turned to CBS Radio's Game Six coverage of the 88th World Series.

           

At one point, a Minnesota Twins runner reached second base. Out of the blue, I heard Scully reference Broadway's Death of a Salesman: its "tiny ship" - the runner at second base - seeking "safe harbor" - home plate. I almost drove off Pennsylvania Avenue. Only Scully could fuse baseball and Arthur Miller: literature in a highlight age.

           

Fast-forward to 2025. A grandchild will savor some announcer. Smiling, we'll recall Scully: in memory, our safe harbor. From baseball, Vin seldom lets us wander far away.

 

New Yankee Stadium Embodies Game's TV Woe

New Yankee Stadium.jpgImagine the baseball in play 8-9 minutes in a three-hour game.  (You don't have to.  It's fact.)  Now picture a television viewer unable to see even that peewee action. (Below, read about the new Yankee Stadium.)  The mix makes baseball video-toxic.  Paraphrasing Churchill, seldom do many watch so long for so little.

 

Baseball's rhythm has been a TV problem since Viet Nam and Watergate.  Yearly the bigs pledge to stop pitchers dawdling; batters stepping in, out, and in the box again; and umpires refusing to call a strike.  If baseball were the Politburo, it would be in the 40th year of its first five-year plan.

 

"Next year," Bud Selig vows of a quicker, better pace.  Next year never comes.  What has: a new problem compounding TV baseball's plight.  A vertical wire and mesh backstop obstructs the home plate camera, often blocking an entire field: akin to watching through Attica prison bars, or peering through a net.

 

The home plate camera is football's 50-yard or hockey's center-ice:  a viewer's picture window; the prism through which we look.  Till the early 1990s, each park perched its camera low, near the field, and above the backstop:  the screen rose 10-15 feet vertically, then angled at 45 degrees to just below or behind the camera, intersecting the top of the lowest deck.

 

The effect was intimate, wire/mesh-unhindered video:  We watched because of, not despite, coverage.  Today every park could use a similar up-close format:  In fact, only Boston does.   Elsewhere, declining local ratings show the madness of out-of-view, out-of-mind.  Yogi Berra said you can observe a lot by watching.  We rarely watch what we cannot see.

 

Last Decade TV Disaster

 

Opening in 1992, Camden Yards rivaled Yankee Stadium and Fenway Park as baseball's most camera-friendly park.  "It's your window on the game," Orioles Voice Chuck Thompson called the home-plate camera, "so you place it near the field."  Each's shot was unobscured by any wire.  All aped the best box seat.

 

In 1994, trouble rose at Texas' The Ballpark in Arlington, designed partly by owner George W. Bush.  (Full disclosure:  I was a White House speechwriter for his dad.)  Inverting custom, cash-hungry Bush fils put the broadcast booth over swanky suites:  home-plate shot players looked like ants.  Add lousy coverage to Bush's Iraq, Katrina, and A.I.G. 

 

Miming W., for 15 years new parks have favored in-person high rollers v. crucial-to-baseball  viewers.  Example:  Instead of angling the backstop, each allows a towering vertical wire backstop to intersect the TV screen.  Baseball calls it "safer":  in truth, the 45-degree wire protects more patrons.  The real reason is contempt:  Baseball doesn't want to bother arranging a screen to serve the paying and viewing customer.

 

The new Yankee Stadium shows the error of mocking television.  The old House That Ruth Built's low home plate shot avoided the backstop.  Today's solely vertical wire screen blocks half the infield.  "Depending on your sense of what a new $1.5 billion park should be," said the New York Post's Phil Mushnick, "impaired-view TV likely lands between annoying and intolerable."  Playoff hockey never looked so good.

 

Incredibly, the team's Yankees Entertainment and Sports (YES) Network didn't investigate camera placement until weeks before the opener.  (Also missing: the old Stadium's birds-eye first- third-base camera wells: "a must for a new big-league park in 1989," said Mushnick, "let alone 2009.")  A YESer added:  "In the old Stadium it was impossible to show a bad angle.  Here it's impossible to show one good."

 

Getting That Was Bad Gets Worse

 

The National Football and Hockey Leagues help teams ensure that TV lures new viewers, including kids.  "When a new arena [or stadium] opens," said an NHL official, "it reflects league input on how to position camera angles." Its home-plate equivalent - 50-yard line and center ice, respectively - is usually near the surface.  By contrast, Selig's office is MIA, even as bigs TV cries SOS.

 

This decade A.C. Nielsen's World Series, All-Star Game, League Championship Series, Game of the Week, and many local-team ratings have dropped.  One reason is baseball becoming intolerably untelegenic.  "Ratings sink," said a Fox TVer, "because how baseball presents itself stinks."  Out-of-sight, out-of-mind.

 

Since 1994, 18 new parks have opened:  e.g., Arizona, Atlanta, Cincinnati, Pittsburgh, San Francisco, St. Louis, Washington, and now New York.  Intimate in person, they are distant on the screen. Many blare players-turned-pygmies.  Most brook a TV wire lattice.  Unlike the NFL or NHL, Selig doesn't seem to care if baseball puts its video house in order. 

 

Make a pitcher throw the ball, umpire call a strike, and batter not leave the box.  Make it constitutional for a game to sing, rock, move.  Angle the backstop below the home plate camera.  Put each park's camera as low as Fenway's.  For what not to do, check Yankee Stadium.  For what to do, check baseball circa 1960.

Merle Harmon: What a Life, and Loss

Merle Harmon b&w.jpgEvery once in a while I am asked the most honorable men I know in broadcasting. Among others, I cite Ernie Harwell, 91-turned-19; Bob Wolff, the USA's long-running sportscaster; and Merle Harmon, dead last week, at 82.

Quoting Shakespeare, Merle was nature's nobleman -- not easy, having worked for Charles O. Finley; aired the Milwaukee-headed to-Milwaukee Braves; and replacing Dizzy Dean on network television. For a time, life mirrored the Twilight Zone:  "more like Alice in Wonderland," he mused. The curiouser and curiouser is how Merle prevailed.

His window on America opened in southern Illinois. Then: Graceland College, the Navy, University of Denver and radio in Colorado. Harmon debuted on a 1949 Class-C doubleheader. "It lasted eight hours, the temperature was 104, and I had a headache," duly noted on the air. A listener wrote: "Don't tell us your troubles.  Broadcast the game." 

Topeka's team bus carried 17 players. Often it stopped, had to be pushed to a gas station, and maxed at 40 miles an hour -- downhill. One rider, pitcher Ebbie Lubanski, bearded owner Joe Magoto: "I'm quitting baseball -- my salary." Joe pulled a gun: "Pitch your next game." Lubanski packed, turned pro bowler, and snubbed meal money: $1 daily.

"The bucks went to the big club," said Harmon. "Other things kept your interest." One was Joplin's 1950 shortstop." At 18, Mickey Mantle already hit balls out of sight." Doing 1952 basketball, Merle improved his. "No more bad passes," Kansas coach Phog Allen said. "You players gotta see things happen -- skip movies -- rest your eyes."

Allen mentioned Max Baer. Doctors told the boxer to visit California, lie on the sand, and look at the stars. "Instead, Max went there," Phog said, "laid the stars, and looked at the sand." Harmon never forgot the vision."

Enter Charlie O.

In 1954, Merle did Kansas City's last Triple-A season. Next year the Athletics relocated. Harry Truman threw out the first ball on Opening Day. Harmon huzzahed illusions: A's 6, Tigers 2. "[Manager] Lou Boudreau, later an announcer, said, 'If your team is good, you can criticize. If it's lousy, show patience.' In Kansas City, I was the most patient man in the world."

The club never matched the '55ers' place (sixth) or gate (1,393,054). Nine skippers left. The A.L. lost K.C.'s 1960 All-Star Game, 5-3, despite a seven-Yanks roster. "[A's owner Arnold] Johnson gave 'em Art Ditmar, Ralph Terry, Roger Maris," said Harmon. "How it goaded us -- 'Yankees cousins.'" The A's once bashed New York for 27 hits. "We felt like the powerhouse. 'Course, the feeling didn't last long."

In December 1960, Chicago insurance broker Finley bought 52 percent of the team. Then Merle snubbed Charlie's "Poison Pen Day" for Kansas City Star sports editor Ernie Mehl. "Ernie got baseball here in '55 -- and Finley's trashing him!" said Harmon. Deeming Merle a traitor, Charlie sacked him in late 1961.

Nietzsche says, "That which doesn't kill you makes you stronger." What happened next made Harmon feel like Charles Atlas. "Out of the frying pan, into the fire."

Both Sides Now

By late 1963, baseball's ex-capital had become a lonely post, drawing 32 percent of 1957's record date. Resigning, Voice Earl Gillespie saw Milwaukee's writing on the wall. Could Merle, replacing him, retrieve its past? Attendance rose? Baseball yawned: only a temporary court order kept the Braves in town. "What a mess. They had to play '65 in a city which knew it was losing them." Mild and upright, Harmon became a loci of curse, slight, and hate.

"Hot? My seat burned. If I praised the Braves, people said, 'Don't root for traitors.' If I didn't, die-hards said, 'Don't mess up another club.'" Upping angst: an N.L. team record six players with 20 or more homers. "How could you not get excited?" Milwaukee vied till September, "baseball afraid we'd make the Series and County Stadium would be empty."

Curiouser: a) Wisconsin swore the Braves' 45-outlet network did games gratis. "A bank and three breweries paid, but wouldn't say so -- guilt by association"; b) WSB Radio Atlanta aired 53 games, 26 from Milwaukee. "One city doing every game even though its team is leaving. Atlanta doing a team it doesn't have"; c) a legend, remerged as ghost.

In 1955, Merle visited Yankee Stadium -- "first time, I'm quaking." Entering the booth, he thought, "My God, it's him." Smiling, Mel Allen said, "Anything you need, let me know." Fired in 1964, he took the next-year Atlanta job to avoid seeming yesterday's dessert. Said Harmon: "We'd have cookouts in my yard and Mel'd pour his heart out about the Yankees" Why? he asked, like Milwaukee.

In October 1965, the Braves marched toward Georgia. Merle's next mission: make Saukeville forget Dizzy Dean.

Going National

August 1961. Since 1955, Dean's CBS TV "Game of the Week" had exteriorized baseball. One morning the phone rang at the A's hotel in New York. "Merle Harmon?" a man said. "Yes," Merle said, half-asleep. "This is Chet ...," the voice said. "Would you be interested in doing a national sports show for ABC TV?" Harmon tensed. A player was plainly kidding him.

"Sure, if I can work it into my schedule. Talk to my agent," Merle jibed. "Who's your agent?" said the man, undeterred. Harmon: "He's tied up." Caller: "We'd be glad to contact him, but can we see you? We're leaving for Chicago today to do the [football] All-Star Game." 

Merle sat up, gulping: "Excuse me. Who are you?" Chet Simmons of ABC TV Sports: "We want to talk to you about a show -- today." Harmon reddened: "I must sound like a moron." Simmons laughed: "Boy, it must be fun to travel with a baseball team."

Next month, Merle began "Saturday Night Sports Final." ABC named him baseball Voice for its new "Game of the Week" in 1965. CBS's series entered only non-bigs cities -- its rub, and beauty. "The heartland was its habitat," said Harmon. By contrast, the blackout of, say, St. Louis hurt.

ABC's "Game" aired Saturday, Memorial and Labor Day, and Fourth of July in every cityMerle Harmon with Jack Brickhouse.jpg. Like Jack Brickhouse, Merle evoked just folks. Like Vin Scully, he dashed cliche. Like Curt Gowdy, he was "breezy, relaxed, and stylish," said TV Guide.

"We had a sense of the 'first ever'," he said, "a prototype for baseball TV since" -- truly national. The problem was habit: weekends meant Dean.

Ol' Diz a New Problem

The Yankees declined to join ABC's 1965 package.  Instead, CBS's "Yankee Game of the Week" slayed Merle in Dallas and Des Moines. Worse, local TV split the big-city audience. "ABC'd show Cubs-Cards in New York, and the Mets'd kill us." Desperate, one Saturday the network tendered a great chatterbox of the time.

At D.C. Stadium, Vice-President Hubert Humphrey joined the booth. "So loquacious, I almost asked him to do play-by-play," Merle said, "but feared it would demean the office." The Nats' Bob Chance pinch-hits. Humphrey says, "Is he related to Dean Chance?" Bob was black, Dean white: Much of America still hailed Jim Crow. "I don't think so," said Harmon, retrieving the game.

Coverage ended Saturday, October 2. Harmon spent Friday phoning New York. Ahead by a game, the National League first-place Los Angeles hosted Milwaukee. If L.A. won, Merle flew to Cleveland -- or via Chicago for the American League champion Twins. A Dodgers loss would revive the second-place Giants -- and put him in San Francisco. Writer Jorge Luis Borges said, "I have known uncertainty." Harmon now bore the "most uncertain 24 hours of my life."

The last plane left at 12:15 A.M. Saturday. "I'll only know where I'm going when I find how the Dodgers do!" Naturally, they went extra innings. At the airport, Merle tells the cabbie to "turn on the game!" L.A. wins. "Let's see, this means Cleveland. Take me to United quick." Finding a seat, he checks the ticket. Panic. "Cleveland? I'm supposed to be in San Francisco!"  Arriving, Harmon calls ABC's hotel. "Yes, Merle, this is your destination." Going home, he was tempted to take a train.

Better Deja Vu in Brewtown

That month, NBC bought 1966-68's "Game." Merle had already aired the Jets and Steelers (local radio) and NCAA and American Football League (ABC). He liked more than respected football. "You're fine if you prepare weekly like a player. Baseball -- try finding something interesting as you say the pitcher throws the ball -- especially if your team is out of the pennant race."

Harmon found Minnesota in 1967. Dean Chance went 20-14. Harmon Killebrew had 44 homers. The Twins drew 1,483,547, more than they had or would at Metropolitan Stadium, and lost a last-day flag. "If we'd beaten Boston [the Sox won, 5-3], I'd have done the Series with [NBC's] Gowdy." He hurt, but shone. "I'll never forget the letter I got from a woman criticizing me for not rooting for the Twins."

Harmon aired them through 1969. On April 1, 1970, his old team bought the Seattle Pilots for $10.8 million. "Calvin Griffith [Twins owner, releasing him] knew what Milwaukee meant to me." County Stadium reopened April 7: Angels, 12-0. "I learned quickly that it'd be a long year" -- too, how the Braves' rape stung. "The feeling was: 'We won't be hurt again.'"

In 1971, Bob Uecker joined Merle in the Brewers' booth.  Harmon trained him, reveling in Uke's growth. By 1973, Milwaukee passed a million for the first time since JFK. Slowly, the feeling warmed. 1975: 48,160 cheered Hank Aaron's return from Georgia. 1978: The Brewers grand-slammed a record thrice in the first three games. 1979: Milwaukee more than tripled the Braves' last-year gate. It was almost better the second time around.

"It took a while," said Harmon, "to get back a decent team, then fans to get excited." The '82ers won a pennant. Curiouser: He was 850 miles away.

Coda for a Grand Career

In late 1979, inking a multi-year NFL TV pact, Merle ogled the 1980 Moscow Summer Olympics. "I'd have missed a dozen Brewers games." Flagship WTMJ demanded he do each. Harmon chose none. "[He] will make more money [NBC]," mused The Milwaukee Journal, "get more exposure, and do less traveling." Merle did "SportsWorld," backup "Game," and 1980 World Series. He did not, alas, call the Games. In December 1979, the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan. America boycotted Moscow. NBC promptly pulled the plug.

"A great letdown," said Harmon. Another: being axed by NBC in 1982 for Bob Costas, 29. What goes/comes around. In 1966, Gowdy replaced him on "Game." Each joined the Rangers in 1982: Merle, play-by-play; Curt, planning and evaluation. A similar cycle was Nolan Ryan's, K-ing 21 Hall of Famers in four different decades. One batted August 22, 1989. "Three and two to [Rickey] Henderson!" said Harmon. "Ryan gives the okay. Strike three! He did it! He did it! Number 5,000 for Nolan Ryan! A record that will never be broken." As usual, Merle was right.

Harmon had each player and umpire sign a scorecard laser print, retiring after three no-hitters, Joe Namath's Super Bowl III "guarantee," and 1974 World Football League, The Los Angeles Times having said:  "He may be the best radio football announcer of all time." Wearable and modest, he exuded class. Routinely I routinely told friends: "If my son [now eight] is half the man Merle is, I'll be one happy dad."

The entrepreneur founded the Merle Harmon Fan Fair, soon the largest U.S. sports souvenir retailer.  Later, the Mormon lay preacher went belly-up, had a heart attack, and beat both -- each a breeze, he joked, vs. Finley, the lame-duck Braves, and Diz.  Merle divided time Merle Harmon with mic.jpgbetween Dallas and Milwaukee, loved his children and grandchildren, and did not forget, and was not forgotten by, his public. Such amalgams are hard to find.

"Every day I do exercise on the treadmill," the still-nobleman mused after a stroke.  Richard Nixon once said: "I get up every morning just to confound my enemies."  Harmon got up to help his friends.  God bless him, and He will.

Harry the K Felt, Bred Brotherly Love

  Kalas headshot.jpgWhen Red Barber died in 1992, Steve Kelley wrote that "some people are meant to be immortal.  Their voices and their visions are meant to continue from generation to generation."  Exemplum: Harry Kalas, this week dying suddenly and stunningly of a heart attack, at 73.

His face belonged in the Vienna Boys Choir. His voice evoked a bass, lead cello, or wrecker razing cars: to Bill Conlin, "a four-Marlboros into a three-martini-lunch baritone. Harry Norbert Kalas, a minister's son, wooed the Delaware Valley, spreading the Phillies' Word.

"It's like Harry had opera training," said long-time vice president Larry Shenk. "No one can call a moment like him." To the Main Line, Brandywine, and Center City, "Long drive ... It's outta here!  Home Run!" was outta sight. Someone will succeed the man whose popularity was more phenomenal than the Phillie Phanatics's. No one will replace him.

In 1944, Kalas, 8, raised near Chicago, visited Comiskey Park for his first bigs game. Rain halted batting practice. "The Senators stunk. I'm praying weather clears, so the Sox'll win.  I go near their dugout," where Mickey Vernon sat Harry on the bench. At that moment he pledged to hit, or call, the curve.

At the University of Iowa, Kalas majored in speech, radio, and TV. A blind professor said, "You have a voice that could take you a considerable way." He was drafted, became a broadcast specialist, and recreated P.C.L. Hawaii. "Road trips were too costly to do live."  The bigs team hiring him was no bargain at any price.

The Colt .45s were a hero of every dog that was under. In 1965, they got a new name (Astros), park (Astrodome), and Voice, but not team. Doug Rader used the clubhouse as a driving range. Larry Dierker explained -- "they wanted to live" -- why no took his clubs.  Once Rader, Joe Morgan, Kalas, and his father golfed.  Increasingly, Doug's language turned blue.

"Ease off," said Morgan. "Don't you know Harry's dad is a [Evangelical United Brethren] minister?" Doug brightened: "Mr. Kalas, I didn't know that.  Jesus Christ!"  Scales fell from pop's eyes like Saul on the Damascus Road." Our heart, not eyes, hurts now.

He'd Rather Be In Philadelphia

Kalas early headshot.jpgIn 1787, Benjamin Franklin wondered during Philadelphia's "long hot summer" whether the sun painted on the president's chair was rising or setting. "But now at length, I ... know that it is a rising, not a setting, sun." In 1970, the sun set on Connie Mack Stadium. Many wondered when decent baseball would rise.

April 1971: Veterans Stadium opens. Kalas, replacing Bill Campbell on Phils radio/TV, finds the city up in arms. "Bill Giles had been [V.P.} in Houston. Coming here, he offered me a job," not saying those. "Bill was very popular. For several years my confidence level faltered." He was not bolstered by the 1971-73ers, dredging last.

"You kept hoping pieces' merge," said Harry. One day Greg (Bull) Luzinski drove deep in batting practice. "Wow, that's way out of here!" gawked Larry Bowa. Nearby the new Voice stood: "It's outta here!" began. Like Kalas, another piece braved a rough initiation. "He came up [1972], and you saw the skill. But he'd miss wildly, make an error at third, and sulk."

In 1975, Mike Schmidt and Luzinski combined for 72 homers. Bowa made shortstop hermetic. "Two-thirds of the world is covered by water," wagged broadcaster Ralph Kiner. "The other third is covered by [center fielder] Garry Maddox." Byrum Saam soon retired, making Harry lead announcer. Finally, the sun began to rise.

"This City Loves It!"

Even Napoleon, said Danny Ozark, "had his Watergate." The Phils skipper and a player had "a wonderful repertoire." Morality, he said of team morale, "is not an issue here." The '76 Bicentennial was. Philly won the National League East -- first title since 1950. Even then," Harry rued, "our luck wasn't great." Two men reached base vs. St. Louis' Al Hrabosky. Maddox smoked an out. The shortstop caught Schmidt's liner, sprawling. Hrabosky deflected and retrieved the Bull's game-ending smash. "We had everybody played right," joshed manager Red Schoendienst, "except maybe Al was a little shallow on Luzinski."

Cincy swept the playoff.  Next year Philadelphia led League Championships Series Game Three, 5-3, in the ninth: two out, none on; 63,719 shook the Vet. "Maybe we were thinking World Series," said Larry. L.A. scored thrice. A day later Phils ace Steve Carlton lost, 4-1, ending the L.C.S. By now Harry the K distilled a region's hope, hurt, and fatalism.

Already he had done, or would, Notre Dame, DePaul, Marquette, Southwest Conference, Big Ten, and Big Five basketball, Irish, University of Houston, and Westwood One's network football, and NFL Films, as co-host/voiceover.  Too: videos, team highlight reels, and U.S. Mint, Sears, Campbell's Soup, and Dilbert's animated cartoon.

"All stemmed from Harry's baseball stage," said Shenk. When would Philly, filling it, fill a rep as Red Sox South? The '80ers again took their division on Schmidt's next-to-last-day blast. The L.C.S. against Houston followed, an 8-7 final aping jai-alai. "Finally, after all these years, a Series!" Kalas chortled -- the Phillies' first since 1950.  There was, as they, a hitch.

Baseball's then-policy barred local-team Classic coverage. "So NBC gets a petition of thousands of names" said partner Andy Musser. "'Let Harry broadcast on [flagship] KYW!'" The Peacocks demurred. Next season, too late for Kalas, the radio ban ended. "I understood NBC," he said. "I just wish I could have done something I'd dreamed of since a kid."

On October 21, at 11:29 P.M., the Phils, 97, won title one. "World champions of baseball!" Kalas, re-creating, roared. "It's pandemonium at Veterans Stadium! All of the fans are on their feet! This city has come together behind a baseball team! Phillies are world champions! This city knows it! This city loves it!" Rising sun: A million Quakers jammed next day's victory parade.

Michael Jack & Whitey

"The [50-day 1981 players'] strike] killed our championship momentum," said Harry. In 1983, a lesser club won the flag: Kalas did the Series in customary white loafers and blue slacks, cigarette in hand, filling a homemade scoresheet. Rose hiked to Montreal. Carlton skipped to San Francisco. Remaining: "There's a smash down the third-base line! What a stop by Schmitty! ... Struuuckhim out! ... Watch that baby go!" In suburban Wallingford, a ninth-grader penned a "favorite person essay."  Kalas' voice "is sleepy and invigorating all at once," Rich Beck, 15, wrote. "It is a beautiful thing."

In 1986, Schmidt won a 10th Gold Glove, led the N.L. for the eighth time in homers, and took his third MVP. Next April 18, he faced Pittsburgh's Don Robinson. "Here's the pitch ... He take a shot at it! There it goes! It is outta here! Michael Jack Schmidt [another Kalas signature] has hit his five-hundredth home run! What a spot! What a spot! And the entire team comes out to greet Schmitty! He puts the Phillies in front, 8 to 6! For Mike Schmidt, his five hundredth homer!"

In the clubhouse, mates cried "We want Harry!" then four times replayed his call. Rising/setting: the Phils twice plunked last; the '93ers won the East. Kalas brayed "High Hopes," his favorite song. Once the team's pear-shaped, green-haired, elephant-nosed mascot crashed the booth, scaled a ledge, and mugged his way around the bowl. "What does it say," partner Richie Ashburn asked Harry, "that you're one of our biggest stars -- and the Phanatic is the other!"

By now, towhead Ashburn -- "Whitey" -- and Kalas had become, by any norm, the team.  "We were friends immediately," said Harry, "and best friends, eventually."  Baseball is routine.  A listener soon anticipated theirs like a pet book or favorite film:  Ashburn, cap and piped blacksmith's son; Kalas, the piano man -- "George Burns," said the Inquirer, "to Whitey's Gracie Allen."

One year the Phils finished next-to-last.  "What are they going to name their highlight film?" said Harry. Richie: "How about, 'The game not so easy.'" Another night:  "Harry, you know I did something Babe Ruth never did." Kalas:  "What's that, Whitey?" Ashburn: "Hit a home run in Dodger Stadium." Pause: "Yeah, Whitey, I guess that Babe Ruth wasn't the player he was cracked up to be."

Ashburn knocked pitchers, baited umpires, and bayed, "Oh, brother" and "Bet the house on it" -- the Inquirer's "most beloved Philadelphian in the world."  Getting an award, Richie told the City Council, "I always wanted to be an institution before I went into one.  The race is pretty close." Tri-staters loved his barb and view: like Kalas, a pal at the corner bar.

In 1995, 50,000 watched Harry's best friend enter Cooperstown.  Two hundred buses drove from Philadelphia.  Phillies red dyed the crowd. "Do I have to treat you any differently now?"
said Kalas.  Whitey: "Yeah, with a little respect."  Jest can ***** a funny bone. Truth can break a heart. On September 9, 1997, in a pone call from Phillies trainer Jeff Cooper, Harry learned that "Whitey just died of a heart attack." Stunned, he sat and sobbed.

Three days later the K gave a eulogy. "Never in [Philadelphia] history has there been such an outpouring of love and affection for our beloved departed friend," Harry began, voice cracking. "Why this overwhelming reaction? Because Don Richie Ashburn was Whitey" gentle and easy as a country breeze, down home, biscuits and gravy, Norman Rockwell come to life." Today that "outpouring" seems to apply to his friend.

"We Have Lost Our Voice"

In 2004, the Phils opened new Citizens Bank Park; Harry, a restaurant, Harry The K's.  At Veterans Stadium you could propose marriage on the scoreboard for $120, Kalas swooning like a schoolboy in 2002. "I'm on cloud nine," he said of the Hall of Fame (also, the team's 2008 world title). "For a kid who fell in love with the game at ten, to be going in ... is mind-boggling." A full house at the Vet, including Mickey Vernon, got bobble head dolls of Mr. K. and Ashburn. Harry toured the field in a convertible: said the Daily News, "as much a local figure at cheese steaks, the Art Museum, and the Summers Strut."

In July, Philly fanatics filled another field near the Hall of Fame, buses again trekking to Cooperstown from Center City. "This is the ultimate honor, " the 19-time Pennsylvania Sportscaster of the Year began. Tearing, he imagined Richie's twist: "Hard to believe, Harry!" ending with a poem that read, "Philadelphia fans, I love you."

Kalas waving.jpgFrom a distance a voice yelled, "And we love you, too, Harry!"  Phils president Dave Montgomery expressed similar love upon Kalas' death, "We have lost our voice."  At such a time, "It's outta here!" seemed less chant than simple definition of his appeal.

 

For Kubek, A Deserved Nod

By 1939, Lou Gehrig was dying of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, a hardening and collapsing of the spinal cord.  On July 4, he gave baseball's Gettysburg Address.  "Some may think I've been given a bad break ... Today I consider myself the luckiest man on the face of the earth."

  Kubek 1958.jpgSegue to 1960.  A World Series break tears limb, not life.  In Game Seven, Gino Cimoli singled to start Pittsburgh's eighth inning.  Bill Virdon grounded to Tony Kubek. "A sure double play," said the Yankees shortstop," except the ball hit something" -- pebble, divot, or Forbes Field rough spot, no one knows -- "and hit me in the larynx."

Tony fell, grabbed his throat, began to choke and cough blood, and was carted to the hospital.  En route, Bill Mazeroski swung.  In 1965, doctors found that Kubek had broke his neck, likely from Virdon's grounder.  Three vertebrae had fused:  a collision could paralyze him.  Ironically, the bad break spun identity:  the average guy knew who Tony was.

Retiring, Kubek, 29, was to fly home to Milwaukee. "I was going to sell [Laughing Cow] cheese," he laughed.  Instead, NBC poo-bah Dave Kennedy cornered him at Mr. Laffs, Phil Linz's Manhattan club.  The Peacocks had just acquired Game of the Week.  Would Tony audition as a backup analyst?  Unlike Gehrig, luck had bounced Kubek's way.  This year it will carry the 1966-94 bigs Voice to Cooperstown.

Home-Town Boy Made Good

On July 26, Tony will become the Hall of Fame and Museum's 33rd recipient of the Ford C. Frick Award for broadcast excellence.  It is an historic pick:  the first analyst-only honoree.  Inducted, Tony may recall a time when teams broke the bank for a bonus baby:  in his case, 1954, each wanting the "painfully shy" 17-year-old who never dated in school.  Papa took a longer view.  "'Forget a big deal,'" said the ex-Triple A Milwaukee Brewer. "Their rules make you stay with the [parent] club."  Dad wanted his string bean to mature in the bushes.  Agreeing, New York gave him just $3,000 to sign.

In 1957, Kubek made the Yanks, became Rookie of the Year, and homered twice in World Series Game Three at -- Milwaukee.  "Local people called my parents, heckling them."  Next year Tony played shortstop, third base, and the entire outfield in one Series game.  "Casey [manager Stengel] liked to be cute."  He was fired in 1960, making Kubek the daily shortstop.  "He'll play there, period," new skipper Ralph Houk said, and did, leading 1961 shortstops in chances per game.

"Don't write about me, write about Kubek," Roger Maris told a writer.  "He plays great every day, and fans don't know."  Maris encored as MVP.  He and Mickey Mantle had 115 homers.  Whitey Ford went 25-4.  "Ellie [Howard, catching] was a star.  Moose [Skowron] at first, Kubek and Bobby [Richardson] up the middle, [Clete] Boyer at third," said Voice Mel Allen.  "Ft. Knox had more holes."

The Yanks hit 240 homers, went 109-53, then won the Series.  Tony got married, was drafted, entered the Army, and returned to home in his first Yanks at-bat.  Thomas Wolfe thought he would never die.  Kubek could not imagine their meridian might end.  Each year Allen and Red Barber invited him on their post-game TV show.  Tony appeared once:  The camera made him twittery.  "I was the last guy you'd ever think of going into it," he said.  At NBC, Kubek began by throwing up.

New York, April 1966.  About fifty baseball, network, and ad officials discuss Game's first year.  Strangely, its primary match -- Detroit-New York, with Curt Gowdy and Pee Wee Reese -- aired everywhere but there. "Blackout rules gave them the B [backup] game," said NBC producer Scotty Connal.  Tony and Jim Simpson beamed Reds-Cubs into Motown and the Apple.

A rain forecast was read for Tiger Stadium.  Another report said that Simpson had laryngitis.  The crowd looked at Kubek.  "If Simpson's got laryngitis and somebody thinks I'm doin' the" -- gulp, national -- "Game alone, I'll be in the bathroom 'cause I'm going to be sick."  Weather cleared.  Simpson healed.  Kubek reverted to the B's.

One Saturday morning the A game was rained out.  "We learned the whole network is our," said Charlie Jones, Simpson's sub. "I'm thrilled.  Everybody'll see us." Excusing himself, Kubek left the booth.  "Thirty minutes before the game, no Tony.  Twenty, no Tony.  Fifteen, no Tony."  Finally, Tony.  "Where you been?" said Jones.  "Throwing up," said Kubek.  "I'm not ready to go national."

By 1968, he was.  "The problem," said Connal, "is being hidden on the backup."  That fall a good Series hop found Tony's glove:  He wowed as a field reporter. "Tony wormed his way around, but I wasn't bitter," said Reese, soon fired.  "I just think if you don't have anything to say, you should shut your mouth."

Kubek had a lot to say, though at first didn't say it well.  "I stuttered, talked too fast," he said.  "In the early ''70s, Curt suggested that I work offseason on my delivery."  Buying a recorder, Tony often read poetry aloud for 20 minutes a day.  One night Monday Game of the Week guest Howard Cosell began trashing baseball.  "No amount of description can hide the fact that this game is lagging insufferably."

"Baseball's athletes top everyone's," Kubek countered.  Cosell smirked, "No, my friend, try auto racing."  Tony was almost speechless.  It did not become a trend.

Honesty His Best Policy

In 1973, NBC launched the "Celebrity in the Booth." Kubek panned it at a network luncheon.  Cosell?  Bobby Riggs?  Danny Kaye?  A great guy, but come on."  Why not Marcel Marceau, Harpo Marx, and Linda Lovelace?  Designated hitter?  "Dumb rule."  Salary structure?  "Complete irrational."  Replacement players?  "I'm a union guy.  They'd have to be called scabs."

Tony called the 1969-75 All-Star Game, L.C.S., and Series.  In 1972, Oakland's Bert Campaneris, knocked down, threw his bat at Detroit's Larrin LaGrow. "It's justified," said Tony.  "Any pitch like that," aimed squarely at Bert's legs, "endangers his career."  Incensed, baseball's sugar daddy, Motown's Chrysler Corporation, phoned Commissioner Bowie Kuhn called, who called NBC, which pressured Kubek.  A day later he stiffed them all.

Would Tony speak offseason?  "Some guys write jokes for you.  It wouldn't be me."  National ads found the can:  "I don't need the money."  Winter meant family.  "I got hunting, coach junior high basketball, and wait for baseball."  To The Sporting News, he had "really no sense of humor, speaks a little too often, and may be too much in love with his sport."  Still, "One listens, as in the 1975 World Series.

Cincy's Cesar Geronimo reached first in Game Three's 10th inning.  Boston catcher Carlton Fisk then flung Ed Armbrister's bunt into center field.  "Armbrister interfered [with the attempted forceout]"! charged Kubek.  Plate umpire Larry Barnett disagreed.  Joe Morgan plated the 6-5 winning run.  Barnett blamed Tony for death alarum.  Later Tony got 1,000 letters dubbing him a Boston stooge."

"It would be unfair to call him the last honest network broadcaster," wrote columnist Jack Craig. "But he may be the most honest."  The critique still stands.

Joe G. and Rapid Robert

In 1976, Gowdy, Tony's favorite partner, was axed for Joe Garagiola.  Game's tone and feel changed.  "I grew up with a baseball of legend," said Lindsey Nelson.  Antipodal:  sport as job, not lore.  "To players, it's a livelihood.  That's how they treat it."  Vin Scully's and Harry Caray's menu starred wine and beer, respectively.  Joe's and Tony's blared meat and spuds.

"A great example of black and white," said Connal.  A pitcher throws badly to third.  "Joe says, 'The third baseman's fault.'  Tony:  'The pitcher's.'"  Media critic Gary Deeb termed "[theirs] the finest baseball commentary ever carried on network TV."  In 1978, Kubek targeted another critic:  Boss George.

"He's got an expensive toy," Tony said of George Steinbrenner.  "Baseball's tough enough without an owner harassing you." Irked, the Yanks' memoed each owner, Kuhn, and NBC about "biting the fan that feeds it."  Tony:  "George likes to use people as pawns."  King George:  "No player will grant [Kubek] an interview."  Tony: "A lot of owners were ready to cave to Steinbrenner's bullying," said Kubek.  Diogenes would not.

Most Voices would kill for an Olympics.  Tony's pact forebade it.  He seemed as immutable as 27 outs until Scully joined NBC, Garagiola became his partner, and Bob Costas joined Kubek on B.  "I'm not crazy about being assigned to the backup game but it's no big ego deal."  NBC's tunicate doubled salary to $350,000.  Costas roved a newcomer, not neophyte.  "I think my humor loosened Tony, and his knowledge improved me."

Increasingly, many preferred them even to Vin's musings and Joe's asides.  Then, in late 1988, Kubek went back to a future where he never expected to reside.

Farewell, Then Cooperstown

 

"I can't believe it," Tony said of baseball leaving NBC for CBS.  On September 30, 1989, he aired the Peacocks' 981st and last Game from SkyDome, having manned Canada's The Sports Network since 1977.  "Kubek educated a whole generation of Canadian baseball fans without being condescending or simplistic," said the Toronto Star.  In 1990, he joined the Yanks' Madison Square Garden Network. Steinbrenner's ode spurned joy.

 

"Kubek's style is not cuddly," wrote The New York Times' Richard Sandomir."  His intensity costs popularity."  Ask Ken Burns and David Halberstam.  "I wouldn't talk with them," said Tony.  "Interlopers coming in to take over our game."  Ex-Commissioner Peter Ueberroth:  "To say that baseball's drug-free [as he had], the big-lie theory lives."  Steinbrenner, firing skipper Bucky Dent:  "If you are really a winner," Kubek told MSG, "you should not have handled this like a loser."

 

Kubek.jpgIn 1994, "the last honest broadcaster" picked up a scorebook, scrapped a final $525,000 MSG year, and simply walked away.  "I hated what the game's become - the greed, the nastiness.  You can be married to baseball, give you heart to it, but when it starts taking over your soul, it's time to say whoa."

 

The moved stunned industry brass.  What could he be thinking?  Actually, priorities that sanity might cheer.  "I want to go home [Menosha, near Appleton] and spend more time with my family" - also, in his new life, teach refugees English.  "I don't need that ego stuff.  I feel sorry for those who do."  He had made enemies - and a name.

 

For 15 years, arguably baseball's best-ever analyst spurned détente, "not watching a single baseball game."  Better late than never.  This year Kubek will visit baseball's birthplace.  His choice is worthy of the place, and man.

 

Frattare, A Pirates Treasure, Retires

Recently, Lanny Frattare announced his retirement after 33 years as the Pirates radio and Lanny Frattare headshot.jpgtelevision prosopopoeia. If a baseball broadcaster is good enough and lasts long enough, he becomes an extended member of the family.   Frattare was, and did. 

"The decision to retire ... was something I have been thinking about and have discussed for some time," Lanny said.  In the end, it became time, shocking Pittsburgh's diaspora of the curious and the crazed.

Greg Brown will become Pirates' senior radio/TV partner, joining Bob Walk, Steve Blass, and John Wehner.  An "exhaustive search will begin" to succeed Frattare, 60, said team president Frank Coonelly:  succeed, not replace.

From There To Here

Segue to, say, April 2009.  A Bucs' fan retrieves Lanny's 1976-2008 daybook: eight managers, nine general managers, two no-hitters, five batting champions, 10 colleagues, 1979 World Series, 1979 and 1990-92 Division Series, and 2,499-2,714 record:  also, two-headed ghost -- Bob Prince and Three Rivers Stadium.  Ultimately, outliving meant outlasting them.

Frattare grew up 250 miles north and west of the then-Steel City.  "Look at big-league guys from Rochester [New York]," he said.  "Hank Greenwald, Pete Van Wieren, Josh Lewin."  Each watched the Cardinals', then Orioles', Triple-A affiliate.  Lanny wasn't picky:  Any bigs aviary would do.

"I'd look at the booth and think, 'This must be the best seat in the house.'"  His hero ruled the Lanny Frattare at the mic.jpgYanks'.  "Everywhere you'd hear Mel Allen.  I got a tape recorder and imitated him,." Mel's voice was rich, clear, and urgent.  Lanny's was deep, stout, and calm.

At 20, the Ithaca College student met two announcers "who got me in the market."  In 1974, airing Triple-A Charleston, he overnighted at pitcher Blass's home in Pittsburgh.  Prince, the Bucs' 1948- paladin, asked Frattare -- dirty, hair askew, having blacktopped Steve's driveway -- to do an inning. 

"If I never get to the majors' again," Lanny said, "they can't take this away."  In October 1975, the Pirates shockingly took Prince's job.  From 65 applicants, Lanny and Milo Hamilton succeeded Bob and Nellie King.  Their problem was Pittsburgh's psyche.  The Gunner filled its core.

Finding An Identity

Prince's ghost was a real as any relative's.  "Ironically, Bob'd buck me up, say to get involved in the community," said Lanny.  A second specter, 1909-1970 Forbes Field, shrouded the Bucs' new home.  "At Three Rivers Stadium, charm had to come from the team, not park."  In Pittsburgh, both meant Pops.  Where Willie the Starge led, even umpires went.

In 1977, manager Chuck Tanner put Stargell's name in the fourth and sixth lineup spots.  Alvin Dark waited till Willie doubled and the second Stargell hit.  "We got two Wilver Stargells!" San Diego's skipper told Doug Harvey.

The ump eyed his scorecard.  "Mr. Dark, I know who Wilver Stargell is and he's not at home plate now.  No matter what the card says, Stargell's hitting fourth and this man up for the second time is hitting sixth -- and I don't care who he is!"

Next season ended in Philadelphia.  "We're trailing the Phils," said Frattare, "but sweep a twin-bill": two games left, 1 1/2 behind.  A day later radios tuned to Bucs then-flagship KDKA at a University of Pittsburgh football game shook on Pops' first-inning slam.  "That's what baseball is about -- a whole city riding on each pitch."

Pops headed the Pirates family.  In 1979, southwest Pennsylvania's melting pot -- Slavs, Poles, blacks, Germans -- sang Sister Sledge's "We Are Fam-i-Lee."  Pittsburgh won the Series v. Baltimore.  Sadly, the Classic, ensuring network exclusivity, banned local-team radio till 1981.

"We came from 3 to 1 [games] behind," said Lanny.  "It'd have been great to call it."  Next week another kind of call cleared his line.

Persisting, Persuading 

"Even during the Series, I knew Milo wasn't going to extend his contract," said Lanny.  "He was done trying to replace the Gunner."  Up:  Frattare replaced Hamilton, not Prince.  Down:  In 1982, the Gunner began local cable-TV.

The '84ers finished last.  Next year a flailing franchise rehired an ailing god.  "I never call myself the 'Voice of the Pirates,'" Lanny said on Prince's return, "because Bob always will be," even after his death that June.  Frattare still heard pleas to sound, well, like, the Gunner.

Bob roared, "We had 'em allll the way!"  Lanny wagged: "There was noooo doubt about it!"  Prince:  "You can kiss it [homer] good-bye!"  Frattare:  "Go ball, get outta' here, it's gone!"  George H.W. Bush once told me, "I'm not Ronald Reagan.  I couldn't be if I wanted to."  Gradually, Lanny gentled skepticism.

The 1990 Bucs rallied on Memorial Day to beat Los Angeles. A year later to the day they edged the Cubs.  "It's Memorial Day all over again!" Frattare whooped.  Assets:  Pittsburgh made three straight L.C.S.  Twice Barry Bonds became MVP.  Debits:  The late-'90ers lost audience and attendance.

In 2000, Stargell threw out the confluence's last first pitch.  Sister Sledge sang two Anthems -- America's, and "We Are Fam-i-Lee."  Three Rivers imploded in 2001.  Lanny took its digital-timer box to 38,365-seat PNC Park.  Light towers, corner pens, and a flat-green roof conjured Forbes.  Downtown rose across the Allegheny River.  Behind right field homers flowed slowly to the Mississippi.

"I've waited all my career for a real baseball park," Frattare marveled.  In 2004, passing Prince, he became the Pirates' longest-running Voice.  The Pirates flunked .500 in 2007 for the 15th straight year.  Scorecards told the tale.  "I've kept them from the beginning. I have almost 4,500":  like their owner, encyclopedic, clear, and crisp.

Increasingly, Lanny tired of baseball's intinerance:  leave a plane, find the hotel, and migrate to the park.  Dugout tale precedes the game.  Tedium succeeds it.  The collector and student of the U.S. Presidency will fill retirement.  The Bucs' task is to fill Frattare's void.  "It won't be easy," said ex-reliever Kent Tekulve.  "He's the history of Pirates baseball for the last 33 years."  

Skip Caray Cable's First Baseball Star

  Thumbnail image for skip_caray1.jpgReviewing the book The Deerslayer, historian Allan Nevins etched "the story of an America now so far lost in time and change that it is hard to believe it once existed."  Skip Caray's death this month, at 68, was hard to believe:  too, the story of how he altered cable television -- and how cable buoyed The Game.

Return to a 1976 baseball now lost in time and change.  Free local-team TV was the big leagues' foundation.  Pay-cable seemed delusional.  Cable systems existed only randomly.  Ted Turner looked at satellite and envisioned it linking them.  He pined to please -- thus, grow.

In 1976, Turner brought the Braves, upped their TV schedule, renamed WTCG Atlanta SuperStation WTBS, and hired the iconic Harry Caray's son.  "The Braves'll tie the sticks to the big-time," Ted said, sagely.  It was an offer even Don Vito Corleone could not refuse.

Cable soon bulged baseball's stage.  In turn, baseball swelled cable's audience.  The pivot was 1982.  "TBS was, just one offering," said Turner.  "People weren't aware how it could sell the Braves a world from Georgia."  That April Atlanta won a bigs record first 13 games:  suddenly, people were.

The streak was "the 'two-by-four' that hit America between the eyes," said Skip's partner, Ernie Johnson."  A Storm Lake, Iowa, sign read "The Atlanta Braves:  Iowa's Team."  In Valdez, Alaska, a Braves Fan Club chapter pooled cash, bought a screen, and renamed its bar "The Braves Lounge."  In a decade, WTBS households leapt 7,000 percent.

"The greatest thing to happen [to baseball] since Bat Day," the Philadelphia Inquirer called cable television.  You can look it up:  Skip Caray became its first star.

Pere And Fils

Before WTBS, Skip had grown up in and around St. Louis, been an all-city high school linebacker, graduated from the University of of Missouri, and aired Triple-A's Atlanta Crackers and the NBA St. Louis Hawks.  "I'm not good-looking or a threat to Twiggy," Caray joked.  "Fortunately, on radio you can't tell."

In 1968, the Hawks moved to Atlanta.  "Best thing that ever happened," Skip said.  "I got my own identity," Caray pere embodying the St. Louis Cardinals.  "Finally, I stopped being Harry's kid." Soon fils occupied a world of hoops, hockey, and football, chucking raw kid for stardom.  The star he wished upon was baseball.  Irony reached it.

In 1954, Jack Buck had joined the Cardinals, at which point Boss Harry sent Milo Hamilton packing.  Under threads connecting, from 1966-75 Milo, now Braves' Voice, was too busy to settle scores.  Hamilton was then axed again, Skip replacing him.  "It was interesting how fans reacted," said Johnson.  "People expected Skip to be Harry."  They were soon disabused.

Harry roared.  Skip intoned.  Dad rose and fell like a ferris wheel.  Son kept an even keel, showing and prizing modesty.  He never forgot once saying:  "Here's the Voice of the Braves, Ernie Johnson."  During break, Ernie said, "If you don't mind, we're all the Voice of the Braves."  One similarity was controversy.  "The worst call by a major league umpire in fifty years!" Skip raged.  "[Ed] Vargo should be fired because he made all umpires look bad."  You could see pop beaming.

"I didn't set out to be different," said Caray fils, more reflexively than defensively.  "My dad was an orphan, a self-made man, more elemental as a broadcaster.  We're just not the same human being."  A viewer never felt obliged to choose one or the other.

The Super SuperStation 

In 1977, Caray added WSB Radio to WTBS.  Celebrating, Atlanta lost 16 straight.  Laughter got Skip through 1981.  Next year rewarded him.  Atlanta won the N.L. West.  A year later it drew a then-record 2,119,935.  A letter to The Sporting News thanked cable "for getting baseball back in the hearts of rural America."  Full circle:  The 1987-90 Braves dredged last.  "Loosen up," Caray told partner Billy Sample.  "We might be the only team in history not to win a game all season."

In 1982, "I got cheered in a restaurant or grocery store," he said.  "Now if I put on shades, I can slink into Kroger's unnoticed."  TSN, among others, noticed.  "Skip is perhaps America's most prominent baseball announcer," then available in 63 million homes 130 times a year.  Even losing, "the Braves have developed a loyalty among many regions distant from a major-league team."

In 1991, son Chip joined Atlanta -- the first bigs' Voice radio or TV grandson.  "How protective     is telling your kid to be quiet?" said pop.  More history:  Three generations of chip_caray.jpg Carays calling a game that year at Wrigley Field.  Harry kicked himself. "If I'd had sense enough before I was born to nickname myself Flip, we'd 'a had Flip, Chip, and Skip" -- the Singing Carays, for our watching and listening pleasure.

Skip's pleasure seemed to peak in 1992's L.C.S. Game Seven':  ninth inning, three on, two out, 2-1, Pittsburgh. "My biggest thrills have been my kids' successes in Little League or school events," said Caray.  "Professionally, it's easy.  Frank Cabrera," singling to plate David Justice and Sid Bream:  Braves, 3-2.

As Bream slid, people in the booth began pounding Skip on the back.  He never knew it.  "I didn't feel it, my concentration calling the play was total.  All I knew was Frank's hit meant the pennant."  Ultimately, partner Pete Van Wieren a.k.a. "The Professor" aired more than 5,000 games with Skip.  "That play showed how his ability to capture the moment was second to none."  An even better "moment" lay ahead

"Yes!  Yes!  Yes!"

The Braves lost the 1992 Classic and 1993 L.C.S.  Finally, they won the franchise's first post-1957 Series.  "Fly ball, deep left-center!" Skip said in 1995.  "Grissom on the run!  Yes! Yes!  Yes!  The Atlanta Braves have given you a championship."  Harry died in 1998.  Skip had an angioplasty, got a peacemaker that triggered airports' metal detecting device, and was busted to radio and Turner South regional TV in 2003.

"He's identified with the Braves.  We want a national feel," a Turner exec explained, bizarrely. Skip shrugged.  "I said, 'Run that by me again.'''  Ratings dropped, leading TBS, having missed the light, to feel the heat.  "It's nice to be back," Caray smiled, reinstated.  "The fans made it happen."  In 2005, what happened was Chip, rejoining Dad in Atlanta after Seattle via Wrigley Field and Fox TV.

Thomas Hardy wrote Life's Little Ironies.  As baseball's first SuperStation, '70s WTBS wowed the small-town and rural ignored by local-team television.  This year the network ditched the Braves for the first Sunday afternoon national TV series since mid-60s Dizzy Dean gilded the monumentally popular Game of the Week.  Its Voice:  the Chip off Skip's block, wowing Di'z's less Malibu than Mayberry.

Skip's funeral was a day before America's Team's announcer would have turned 69. On Sunday, August 10, airing TBS' Red Sox-White Sox, Chip termed Dad "my hero and best friend."  At a next-day memorial service, Monsignor Tom Kenny gave a eulogy:  "Caray is coming home ... can he make it?  He slides!  He's safe!  Listen to the crowd!"

We did:  Skip let us.  The crowd that was America won't soon forget his voice falling lightly on the ear.

 

For Niehaus, Cooperstown Twice the Fun

Niehaus headshot.jpgIn Winesburg, Ohio, Sherwood Anderson wrote "how at the same instant, and if the people of the town are his people, one loves life so intensely that tears come into the eyes."  To baseball, the Hall of Fame means love, memory, and legends on a giant scale.  Mariners announcer Dave Niehaus has never been to America's most famed small town.  "Thankfully," he mused, "that's about to change."

On July 27, Niehaus will receive the Hall's 2008 Ford C. Frick Award for broadcast excellence.  First, on May 24, he will buoy its Voices of The Game series from the shrine's Bullpen Theater.  "After all these years," said Dave, "I'm making up for lost time," about to discover how Cooperstown can be twice the fun.

Niehaus grew up in a small-town 1950s Indiana of farms and fields and boys playing basketball, often visiting the Palace Pool Rome in Princeton, current pop. 8,175.  Each inning a man, dipping chalk into water, posted a tickertape score on the chalkboard.  Dried, it illumined, say, Cardinals-Cubs.  "I can still see the brilliant white against the dark."

At night, Dave sipped lemonade, caught fireflies, and heard Harry Caray on the porch.  In 1957, he graduated from Indiana University, joined the military, and did Armed Forces Radio. "I'd call games from Yankee Stadium," then Dodger Stadium and the Angels' Big A.  Taking  an apartment in North Hollywood, Neihaus befriended unknown actor Jim Nabors: surprise, surprise, surprise.

In 1977, Dave fashioned the Mariners' Northwest Opening -- their first and still only Voice.  "It's been a wild wholly Pier Six brawl," Niehaus said one night, "and the bullies so far have been the Kansas City Royals."  Number One on this Dave's list:  shunning muted tints for bold pastels.

From Anaheim to Seattle

"Say Dave, you think Seattle," Caray once said.  Many recall his rowing before the expansion M's set sail.  In 1969 and 1973, Niehaus and Don Drysdale, respectively, joined the Angels.  Each worshipped a deity.  "Scully started the West Coast tradition of don't cheerlead or make excuses," said Dave.  How good were they?  "Opposing Vin, we lived to tell the tale."

"I'm going to have dinner tonight at Singer's house," Drysdale once said, apocryphally.  Niehaus asked, "Bill Singer, the pitcher?"  Big D smiled:  "No, Dave.  The singer is Frank Sinatra."

In 1977, the bigs reclaimed Seattle.  "[Owner] Danny Kaye knew me on the Angels [also, Rams football and UCLA hoops]," Niehaus said, "and offered me the job."  He balked.  Kaye persisted.  Dave finally embraced Puget Sound.  "I sit on my deck watching boats on the lake, listening to birds.  It comes to us from God."  Godawfulness sprang from what Niehaus dubbed The Tomb.

"A large mausoleum that gives... the impression of being a poorly lit, damp basement with a beat-up old pool table in the middle," Newsday called the Kingdome,opening April 6, 1977.  "People ask my favorite memory," Dave said.  "It's that night -- against the Angels."  Later the roof leaked.  Balls struck speakers, hit support wires, and entangled streamers.

The ceiling was built to dim the echo of dinky crowds.  Designers knew their team. "It was so Niehaus behind the mic.jpgquiet," said outfielder Jay Buhner, "you could hear fans knocking you."  Most slowly warmed to Niehaus.  "People had wanted a local guy."  He never blamed Seattle.  "People knocked us as a baseball town.  I'd say, 'You fans don't owe us anything, we owe you a team.'" 

Dave's trademark "My, oh, my!" rose at Anaheim.  His early tater call was duller:  "It's gone!"  In 1978, hearing Seals and Crofts, he affixed "Fly Away" to each M's dinger.   S&C also sang "Summer Breeze."  Lenny Randle's turned personal.  A batter bunted toward third base.  "Lenny knew the Kingdome's flat on the base paths."  He got down on all fours trying to blow the ball foul.

"We might be stuck in traffic or mowing the lawn," the Post-Intelligencer said, "but where we really are is the Kingdome because Niehaus takes us there."   Refusing to fly away was the Mariners' ill wind.

Onward, Upward

Seattle flunked.500 its first 14 years.  "Oh, for a place like Fenway," Dave dreamt amid the mourning.  "I genuflect when I walk through the gates.  You see where Ted Williams played."  No one confused The Kid with any Mariner.  "Yet [despite] virtually nothing to recommend them," said a writer, the M's percentage of radios in use was baseball's best.  Their announcer was stud.

"I've had offers to leave, but why be miserable in New York or Chicago?" said Dave.  "I want to be here when we turn around."  The U-turn began in 1989 with Ken Griffey, Jr., 19, son of the Reds outfielder.  Two years later the Mariners finally made .500, drew a record 2,147,905, and vaunted Junior's franchise-high .327.  Griffey smacked 40 homers before the August 1994 strike.  A year later, the M's asked the state legislature to build a park.  Pols snorted a belly laugh.  "We had no leverage," said Niehaus, who found that in its 19th year a team's luck could change.

Gutting a 13-game Halos lead, Seattle won an A.L. West playoff.  Briefly, the Northwest forgot the NFL Seahawks.  The Division Series began in New York, the M's losing twice.  Dave threw out the first ball at the Kingdome's post-season inaugural:  Randy Johnson,7-4. Next day Edgar Martinez slammed:  11-8.  In two weeks Seattle had become a baseball town.  The final showed why.

Eighth inning: M's tie.  Ninth:  Manager Lou Piniella inserts Randy.  "He'd pitched two days earlier.  But he was the best we had."  Eleventh:  Yanks retake a 5-4 edge.  Payback followed.  "Swung on and lined down the left-field line for a base hit!   Here comes Joey, and Junior to third base ... and they're going to wave him in!  The throw to the plate will be late!  The Mariners are going to play for the American League championship!  I don't believe it!  It just continues!  My, oh, my!"

That winter the legislature OKd $320 million.  "Once in a while, I'll think of what saved baseball here," Dave still says.  "1995."

Painting Cooperstown

No longer was Dave a Monet, etching a paint-by-number team.  In 1996, he brooked two angioplasties, abandoned vodka, steak, and Marlboro cigarettes, and drew shortstop Alex Rodriguez's first full season akin to Cronin, Wagner, and Banks.  Griffey became the A.L.'s ninth unanimous MVP.  The '97ers drew 3,192,237, many from Idaho, Oregon, Utah, and Montana.  "For the first time," said Niehaus, "we became a regional team."

safeco.jpgJohnson and Junior left for Houston and Cincinnati, respectively.  A-Rod got an A+ deal:  $252 million from Texas, then New York. "Damndest thing," said Dave. "They leave, we win" -- a 2001 record-tying 116 games.  MVP Ichiro Suzuki hit .350.  The Kingdome imploded.  Its replacement, Safeco Field, strutted arched windows, bleacher, and look from its upper deck of Elliott Bay, Mount Rainier, Olympic Mountains, and ferries, ships, and sunsets from Albert Bierstadt.

Outside, the Burlington Northern freight whistle invoked rural Indiana.  "These trains going by are the park's signature," said Dave.  "To me, it s a romantic sound."  Another knit the stands.  Johnson was "humming along."  A strike "had some hair on it, baby."  Enjoy "a nice little pitchers' duel."  Blurted ESPN's Jon Miller:  "It's all here, it's gorgeous, it's got Niehaus, it's open air!"  Dave could be forgiven for feeling he had been paroled.

In 2000, he became the first member of the M's Hall of Fame.  "I really feel as if I know each ... of you," Niehaus told the crowd.  "My, oh, my!" graced a banner, forged a chant, and was drawn by grounds help in the dirt. Sans fielder "loping," runner "lumbering," or ball "Belted! Deep to right field!  Upper deck time!  Yes!" would there have been a team for Safeco to even house?

In 2000, the Seattle Times named the two-time Washington Sportscaster of the Year "one of the top 10 most influential [local] people of the century."  A 2004 Sports Illustrated survey asked Washingtonians their favorite team.  The Mariners got 56 percent; Seahawks, 10.  Next:  favorite announcer.  Thirty-six percent named Dave.  John Madden's 8 was runner-up.

Some ask which all-time Voice most loves baseball.  Niehaus makes the cut.  "Finally," he says, "what a joy to call good players in a great park!"  The 1930s bred the Hudson Valley school of painting.  Dave's school swabs the Sound.  Soon, it will enrich Cooperstown.

 

Bowie Kuhn: Man of Substance Served Baseball In Style

America's great divide is not right v. left, rap v. bluegrass, or Bud Light v. Tanqueray:  Instead, it splits into style v. substance.  Style is outer-directed.  Substance turns inward.  People of style love trend.  People of substance deem decency deep-down.  This week a man of substance was elected to the Hall of Fame -- the man who ushered baseball into the Television Age.

Bowie_kuhn Baseball has had nine Commissioners since the post's 1920 creation.  Bowie Kuhn was the fifth (1969-84) -- and in many ways, the best.  We judge a leader by how he finds, and leaves, his job.  Kuhn found baseball on a respirator.  He left the summer game in bloom.

Kuhn, who died this year at 80, grew up in Washington, his Senators the Atlantis of the American League.  "I never had to tell who was winning.  People knew," said announcer Bob Wolff.  "I only had to give the score."  Adversity strengthened Kuhn, priming him to swim upstream.

In a 1964 Harris Poll, 48 percent of America named baseball their favorite sport. Half that did when Kuhn became Commissioner.  Forbes mourned "our beat-up national sport," too bland, it seemed, for a hip and inchoate age.  Aping a 1971 film, baseball resembled sport's Last Picture Show.  Kuhn vowed that the last would be first.

He opposed free agency, fearing a caste system:  teams with the gold rule.  Baseball brooked five work stoppages, but expanded from 20 to 26 teams.  Attendance doubled.  Postseason swelled:  the League Championship Series.  Kuhn KOd the designated hitter, tired of a pitcher trying to hit:  dull as seeing paint dry, hearing George W. Bush speak, or reevaluating Al Gore.

Kuhn fined Ted Turner, for player tampering, and George Steinbrenner, for illegal campaign funding.  Above all, he understand television's role, and need.  In 1969, baseball had one network series:  NBC's Game of the Week.  Worse, pro football blanketed TV syndication.  Kuhn craved a weekly half-hour show of highlight, lowlight, feature, and other fare.

First, he inked a dual-network ABC/NBC pact.  Joe Garagiola replaced Bowie_kuhn_2 phlegmatic Curt Gowdy.  Kuhn tried to bounce Howard Cosell, touted Al Michaels and Vin Scully, and created This Week In Baseball :  syndicated sports highest-rated serial.  Ultimately, no baseball series so bespoke one man:  host Mel Allen, hired by Bowie Kuhn.

Kuhn moved the World Series schedule from weekday to night ("Working men can't see day games") but kept weekend's in the afternoon ("for kids, our next generation").  The balance thrived till his successor made the Series all-nocturnal:  also, killing Game and spurring salary collusion.  Peter Ueberroth was a shallow, glib poseur:  a stylist, to the core.

By contrast, under Kuhn, baseball regained parity with the NFL.  His reward was a 1980s firing.  "What's dumber than football's dumbest owner?" said Orioles don Edward Bennett Williams. "Baseball's smartest owner."  Some writers seemed as dumb. Kuhn was formal:  how old-timey.  A devout Catholic:  how bourgeois.  A model family man:  how square.  His foil was players union leader Marvin Miller. The New York Times, among others, never forgave Bowie, then or now.  Forgetting nothing, it learned nothing, too.

Recently sports economist Andrew Zimbalist bayed that "Kuhn never did anything enlightening."  Bitter over Miller's rejection by the Hall of Fame Veterans Committee, Timesman Murray Chass tarred Kuhn's "legacy as unclear."  On what 1969-84 planet did such ideologues live?  Emerson wrote of Napoleon, "He was no saint, to use his word, no capuchin, and he is no hero in the high sense."  Neither saint nor hero, Bowie was a good man who each day went out and did his job.

Kuhn's Hall election honors, among other things, his fine private sense of humor.  This Induction Day, the last laugh will be on those who could, or would, not grasp his substance:  still blind as a bat, deaf as a doorknob, and dim as a burned-out bulb.

"Ratings Sink Because Product Stinks"

The book Fiasco describes George W. Bush's can't win, leave, or understand war in Iraq.  Its title also etches much of baseball's pre-World Series post-season television. Paraphrasing Churchill, seldom have so many watched so long for so little.

Baseball's bust evokes a mosquito in the nudist company, not knowing where to Bud_selig start.  Perhaps with ratings, biting the bigs' behind.  Bud Selig hallucinated, "Baseball interest is [sic] legendary."  Actually, early post-season's was largely sick, limited to playoff cities, the hard-core viewer, and increasingly, insomniacs.

Network suits like to say that less is more.  Here less was less.  TBS' first-ever League Championship Coverage bred the four least-ever watched L.C.S. games.  Only 2.8. per cent of U.S. TV households watched Rockies-Diamondbacks.  ESPN's Chick A-Fil-A Bowl bared 3.7 percent, ABC's Little League World Series final 3.3, last year's L.C.S. 10.5 million viewers v. this year's 4.3.  "Legendary" interest?  Fox's Are You Smarter Than a 5th-Grader? had a larger audience.  Baseball gave a dinner, and almost no one came.

Ironically, TBS' Division Series ratings had jumped 26 percent over last year's Fox/ESPN, airing glamor teams in New York, Chicago, Boston, and L.A.  Fox's Hub-Cleveland L.C.S. actually topped 2006's, Red Sox Nation again blaring the devoted and the crazed.  By contrast, the National League was ignored like last week's mashed potatoes.  Its fiasco should teach Selig two things, neither of them good.

First, shrinking interest mocks the view that marquee local clubs can compensate for the bigs' peewee marketing and network TV niche.  "Good cities, good ratings," said a Foxer, "bad cities, bad."  The 2007 Rockies never graced a Fox, ESPN, or ESPN2 game. The Red Sox blanketed 24. Pro football's lure carries each of its 32 franchises.  Baseball foolishly relies on a couple clubs -- Sox, Mets, and Yankees et al -- to carry it.

NFL interest soars because its network TV product is quick, compact, and riveting. "The game sells itself," said NFL FIlms' David Plaut.  "It almost doesn't matter who makes post-season."  Selig's second lesson is how televised baseball can be intolerably uncompelling.  "Network ratings stink," mused a Foxer, "because how TV baseball presents itself stinks." 

Reasons

From Here To Eternity.  Even 2-1 games now routinely top three hours.  N.L. L.C.S. Set 2 took 4 hours, 26 minutes, a Red Sox-Indians match an insufferable 5:14.  Author Stephen King was shown reading a book between innings.  During innings he could have read War and Peace.  "In fan time, pitching changes equate to a day spent at the D.M.V. or the return line at Macy's," wrote The New York Times' Selena Roberts, scoring baseball's "slow-drip cadence." Pitchers dawdled.  Batters stepped in, out of, and back in the box.  Umpires did everything but enforce the strike zone.  Viewers did everything but stay awake.   

Scheduling spurred the stupor.  Several games began at 10 p.m., slighting the populous East.  "Hard to watch," Mel Allen once said, "if you're asleep."  Awful camera coverage hurts at any time.  A typical game may put the ball in play 8-10 minutes.  What happens when you can barely glimpse it?  Post-season accented baseball's refusal to make coverage camera-friendly.  Yogi Berra said you can observe a lot by watching.  Fans can't observe what they can't see.

Baseball's home-plate camera is TV's picture window: a prism through which we watch.  "It's your mirror on the game," Allen said, "so place it low, near the field."  Fenway Park's or Yankee Stadium's exquisitely low home-plate shot is unobscured by a vertical wire backstop.  By contrast, Cleveland's and Arizona's home plate camera is so high post-season players looked like ants.  Worse, Anaheim's and Colorado's wire screen blocked half the infield, like peering through prison bars.  We watch despite, not because of, coverage.

Jon_miller_13 October's most vocal criticism, announcing, was actually a fall guy for larger flaws.  Jon Miller, Dan Schulman, and Dave Campbell aced ESPN Radio. (Joe Morgan, sadly, was Joe Morgan.)  Fox's Joe Buck sprightly re-emerged from his post-August 4 bigs sabbatical.  TBS studio and analyst coverage was benign, if banal.  Division Series ball and striker Don Orsillo adeptly tied insight, bite, and tone. 

Alas, D.S. Yanks-Indians Voice Chip Caray was vilified, clearly unfamiliar with the American League. The New York Daily News' Bob Raissman dubbed the Braves' broadcaster "unsinkable," wishing Caray sunk.  The Post's Phil Mushnick termed "his command of baseball language and concepts so confused that he's like traveling by pinball." USA Today's Michael Hiestand mocked Caray's calling the D'Backs "hole the size of the Grand Canyon here in Arizona." 

Chip gave Richard Sandomir "agita," The New York Timesman detailing "a skein of faux pas.  No fact is safe in the hands of TBS' lead baseball announcer," he wrote, bewailing "errors and silly strategy."  In fact, Allen, Red Barber, and Vin Scully couldn't have saved baseball's early post-season from itself.

Solution

Pro football is a national sport only incidentally regional, not caring which teams make the Super Bowl or AFC/NFC title game.  Baseball has become a regional sport only incidentally national.  As John F. Kenedy once said, "Our problems are man-made.  Therefore, they can be solved by man."  Baseball's problems are self-made:  therefore, they can be solved by baseball.

Earth to Bud:  Make the pitcher throw the ball, umpire call a strike, and batter not leave the box.  Make it constitutional for a game to sing, rock, moveAngle the backstop below the home plate camera, avoiding a wire lattice across the screen.  Then, put each park's camera as low as Fenway's.  America won't watch players-turned-pgymies on the field.

It is too late to reverse George W. Bush's fiasco.  It is not too late to reverse baseball's.  Perhaps this offseason Selig will help put the bigs' TV house in order.  He'd better, given how America, tuning out, just voted overwhelmingly to condemn.